Substitute for Manchego Cheese

It’s a Spanish cheese that is made from whole cow’s milk. It has a strong combination of salty, sweet, and zingy flavors all in one bite. It’s matured for at least three months. You can incorporate it into any food item, including pasta, risotto, and even pasta; however, the preferred method is on toast with olive oil and tomatoes and use substitute for manchego cheese shared below in its absence. While it’s delicious, it’s also healthy. It’s high in mineral content – calcium, magnesium, and potassium- which are essential to an optimum diet.

The La Mancha region makes it of Spain by consuming the milk produced by Manchega sheep. The milk source provides a distinctive taste to cheeses, making it a favorite in every kitchen. The flavors become more intense as the cheese ages, and the texture gets more granular and flaky.

The inclusion of Manchego in cheese platters is no longer a trend. More often, it is added to sandwiches, pies, or salads, as well as anything else that includes melty cheese. 

manchego cheese in wooden tray image

Alternatives and Substitutes for Manchego Cheese

Tuna casserole mac n’ cheese and the French traditional Croque Madame all benefited from this type of cheese. But what happens if you don’t have it in your refrigerator? If you don’t have a special cheese store close by or a store that has it, you’ll require a substitute for Manchego. Although you’ll never replicate the taste perfectly, alternatives are easier to come across. 

It certainly is a type of cheese that you must try when you get a chance. However, until then, you can try these alternatives that could mimic the flavor of Manchego. Let’s take a look at the top options.


Another excellent alternative is Asiago. It is a cheese from Italy and comes in various varieties, based on how old it is. As it becomes older, Asiago cheese becomes drier and less crumbly. However, fresh Asiago is much more smooth in inconsistency and a great alternative to Manchego cheese. 

It’s an excellent cheese to consume as it is hard, grated, or even melted into a smooth snack, which is the reason Asiago Presto is an excellent alternative to Manchego cheese. You can substitute Asiago cheese in place of Manchego cheese, and the dish will still be delicious. 

There are two types of Asiago cheese that you can make in place of Manchego cheese. Fresh Asiago cheese, known as Asiago Pressato and matured cheese is referred to as Asiago D’allevo. They taste the same; however, the texture is different. 

Freshly made Asiago is more smooth than the crunchy texture of older varieties. The best way to use this cheese is to use it in salads, soups, and sandwiches. You can also melt it in a baking dish or eat it plainly as thin slices. Pick the kind that matches your dish the best.

Asiago cheese image


Parmesan is a different Italian cheese often utilized as the final ingredient on the pasta dish. It is well-known for its crumbly appearance and an aroma that is perfect for food, but what exactly is Parmesan composed of? Parmesan is not named because of the region it was produced in; instead, it has its name because of the process used to make it.

To qualify as Parmesan is to be made using cow’s milk regularly feasting on hay and fresh grass. The food habits of cows influence the caliber of milk produced and contribute to the Parmesans distinctive flavor and texture. Parmesan also has a strong odor, just like most cheeses do.

This helps to enhance its natural nutty flavor. Although you might have thought about Parmesan on pasta before, it is great to be used in various other dishes. This is the reason it is an excellent substitute in place of Manchego cheese.

If you’re a fan of salty cheeses, you can replace your Manchego cheese with Parmesan. It has a distinctive flavor that can enhance the flavor of nearly every recipe. It is great in pizza and pasta dishes; however, you can bake it and mix it into soups and salads. Parmesan is saltier than other types of cheese, so make sure you measure your amounts properly. If you’re looking to increase the amount of Parmesan, do not add salt. If you don’t, the dish may be too salty.

Parmigiano Reggiano cheese is also known as Parmesan, is a firm Italian cheese with distinctive nutritional qualities. A millennia-old manufacturing process produces this famous Italian cheese, which results in its distinctive taste and texture. 

parmesan cheese image


Chihuahua is more than just an oblique name for a dog breed; however, it’s also a delicious type of cheese you can make instead of Manchego cheese. The cheese comes directly from the Mexican State in Chihuahua. Although you might think that this cheese is somewhat spicy because of its Mexican origins, this is not the situation. In reality, Chihuahua cheese is quite similar to Cheddar cheese.

Chihuahua cheese is pale with a yellowish tint and tastes like Cheddar. It is mildly salted and has a delicious taste that only gets better when consumed in different ways. Although Chihuahua cheese is generally hard in its form, similar to Cheddar, it tastes amazing when it melts; therefore, if you’re looking for incredibly delicious and gooey cheese, Chihuahua may be a good option.

It’s great for Mexican food items like quesadillas and chilaquiles, as well as other sauces. The cow milk is used to make the cheese, providing it a light color and a smooth flavor that you can use in many recipes. Because it is a Mexican cheese, it is commonly referred to as Queso Chihuahua. The process of melting this cheese is perfect because it has a similar texture to cheddar cheese. 

chihuahua cheese image


Mozzarella is among the most authentic Italian cheeses. It’s a common milk cheese that has a stringy and gooey texture. Mozzarella is the most suitable answer for the query of ”what toppings should I add to my pizza? 

It’s impossible to go wrong with this kind of cheese. It’s among my top versatile cheeses that don’t alter the flavor of your food, whereas it enhances it and is absorbed immediately.

Mozzarella comes from cow or buffalo’s milk. It has a milky taste and a semi-soft texture; however, it’s still thought of as a soft cheese. It’s a fantastic melting cheese that is a great addition to fondue, baked dishes, pizzas, sandwiches, and other foods.

Also used as a cheeseboard, a wonderful alternative to Manchego cheese is Mozzarella which can be used in more dishes than just pizza. It’s great with sandwiches, as well as sauces, Mexican dishes, as well as Italian dishes. The gooey flavor makes it as good or superior to Manchego cheese in any recipe. It has a pleasant scent, so it will not cause any ill effects when you include it in your recipe. However, it forms a taste that is exactly what you’re looking for.

You can find it in nearly every cheese section. It’s the best choice when you have children who do not like various other varieties of cheese available.

Mozzarella is a popular cheese that people love. It shares the same melting qualities as manchego, making it an excellent substitute for pasta, pizza, or other meals cooked. want to about its storage then checkout our post on freezing Mozzarella cheese in freezer.

can you freeze mozzarella cheese

Monterey Jack cheese

If you’re in search of an American cheese that will take the place of the Manchego cheese, then you’ll be happy to know the fact that Monterey Jack is one of your top choices. Originating from California, it is manufactured from cow’s milk. Its texture is a bit firm and soft but also with a slight flavor. Because of its buttery taste, it works well in cooking various dishes.

For example, if you plan to bake something that uses Manchego cheese, choose Monterey Jack cheese instead. Monterey Jack was first manufactured in California and became a hit for cheese lovers across the US immediately. It is frequently used in numerous Mexican recipes due to its melting properties and tasty flavor. The fame quickly grew, and today Monterey Jack is a favorite for cheese lovers worldwide.

The traditional way of eating Monterey Jack is of mild and creamy texture. It is now more well-known as an incredibly spicy cheese. It is still possible to purchase the classic, mild Monterey Jack, but its dry and pepper versions which are little bit spicy have become the most sought-after varieties. So, if you’re looking for an alternative to Manchego cheese, then you must look into offering Monterey Jack a try. 

If you’re using it to make an appetizer, you might want to consider an alternative like pecorino or parmesan to achieve the nutty taste that goes perfectly with the fruit. Monterey Jack is a recommended alternative for those seeking a less expensive cheese. It’s perfect for those who prefer a less complicated, more common cheese. 



You can also try Zamorano cheese as an alternative to Manchego Cheese. It comes from Spain and is unique from the other cheeses. People sometimes consider it because it is made from sheep’s milk. The cheese is very similar to Parmesan and Pecorino Romano because the manufacturing process must be precise.

For Zamorano, production is dependent on a particular type of sheep for the production of the milk, as the milk has to come directly from Churra or Castilian sheep. The Spanish cheese made from sheep’s milk makes a delicious queso dip. The cheese’s name is derived from the region in Spain that it comes from. It is also different from the other cheeses that we have examined. It is extremely soft and crumbly.

It is very buttery tasting and has a sweet twang that is partly due to the high-fat content present inside this cheddar. This being said, most cheeses are high in fat, and this shouldn’t keep people off taking a look at Zamorano. If you’re looking to explore something new, Zamorano could prove to be the ideal choice for your needs.

Muenster Cheese

Muenster was originally a French cheese, but it’s been modernized, and now there are a variety of varieties of Muenster. The one that is adored more is the American version. Muenster comes from the pasteurization of cow’s dairy. It is pale yellow with a rind that is orange because of the amaretto as a food coloring.

The flavor of the cheese Muenster can be mild, sweet, or sharp, based on the process of aging. It’s a versatile cheese in its ability to mix with other food items. It can be used on pizzas, topping for burgers, and great table cheese.

Muenster cheese image

FAQ’s for manchego cheese

What are the common dishes to make with manchego cheese?

One of the most common ways to use Manchego is Spanish tapas, typically served with Serrano Ham and marinated olives and bread. Manchego is delicious in its form or goes well with sun-dried tomatoes, olives, or figs, and nuts such as hazelnuts, almonds, and walnuts.

What is the manchego cheese smell?

Manchego is one of the most renowned and distinctive flavors of any hard cheese. It is also famous for its distinct yellow appearance. One of the most well-known characteristics is the hatching or crossed patterns visible on the cheese’s rind. The process of creating this is done by traditional presses used to make the cheese. Remember that the cheese’s rind is not edible.

Try to focus on your cheese’s middle as it is the softest section of cheese. In the first taste, you’ll notice a strong citrusy, fruity flavor and, sometimes, a nutty taste followed by a slightly salty flavor. The complex, rich flavors make Manchego a great choice for various applications, such as accompanying pasta dishes or adding to desserts and bread.

What kind of milk is used to make Manchego?

Produced exclusively from sheep’s milk and made from just Manchega Sheep, Manchego is distinctive with its bright, lasting flavor.

What does manchego cheese do?

The powerful flavor and the crumbly texture make it an excellent table cheese. It’s delicious when served with tomatoes, olives, sun-dried, crusty bread, and strong dry sherry or red wine. Manchego is also perfect to use for barbecue.

Rate this post

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *