How To Thicken Alfredo Sauce

Alfredo sauce is made from butter, heavy cream and parmesan cheese. Alfredo is a pasta sauce that does not use tomatoes. Instead, it uses dairy products and omits all vegetables. Many chefs add seasonings to their dishes, such as parsley, salt, garlic, or Italian seasoning. The ingredients may seem simple, but the flavor is extraordinary! This hearty and cheesy combination can elevate any dish.

Alfredo sauce is made with pasta in Italy, where it was created. The ingredients are mixed and then tossed into a bowl to coat the pasta. Both are acceptable. You can find the directions below for each method. Fresh Alfredo sauce made from fresh ingredients is preferred. It’s also very simple to make, so you should avoid buying it in a jar.

if you want to know for how long does pasta sauces like Alfredo sauce etc. last in fridge for reuse then this post will guide you to make the best pasta by reusing the sauces later.

homemade-alfredo-pasta-sauce thick.jpeg

Homemade Alfredo Sauce Vs Store

You can buy Alfredo sauce in jars and refrigerated containers. Some commercial products contain cream cheese or other food starches such as thickeners. This can cause the sauce to lose its flavor of butter, cream, Parmesan and cream.

It will taste fresher, and the three ingredients in Alfredo sauce will come out more clearly. Homemade Alfredo sauce takes only minutes to make.

You can use Alfredo sauce from a store to make these delicious recipes: Lemon-Caper Tuna and Naan, Chicken Alfredo Pot Pies, and Tortellini Alfredo With Roasted Peppers. You can substitute the sauce in these recipes with your homemade Alfredo sauce.

Once you are an expert at making Alfredo sauce, stock up on butter, cream, Parmesan cheese, and garlic. You’ll never be far from an Italian-inspired, cozy meal in less than 30 minutes.

How do you thicken?

Alfredo sauce should be rich, velvety and creamy. It should also be thick and smooth.  Alfredo sauce is a popular recipe people prefer to make at home due to its easy availability and quick preparation time of just 15 minutes. It can be difficult to make homemade Alfredo sauce thin enough to avoid disaster. But, we have some tips that will save you from this.

There are many ways to thicken sauces. Some may work well for you, and some you might not. These methods may not be compatible with all recipes. We have listed a few options to save your sauce while retaining the rich and creamy flavor alfredo sauce is known for.


  • Add Parmesan Cheese

Alfredo sauce is made from cheese, so it’s a good idea to add a lot of cheese to thicken it. You won’t eat Alfredo if you are on a diet. So don’t be afraid to add cheese!

Freshly grated parmesan cheese is your best option. Freshly grated cheese thickens much better than pre-shredded cheese. Other cheeses are also good, including sharp provolone and mozzarella.

It is important to shred the cheese yourself, as pre-shredded cheese will not melt either. Mix the cheese with the boiling sauce.

  • Reduce Heavy Cream

You can thicken alfredo sauce by reducing heavy cream in the cooking process before adding the cheese. To make alfredo sauce, the heavy cream should be reduced by half. If a recipe calls to use one cup of heavy cream, reduce it until it is about 1/3 cup. The water content will evaporate, leaving behind a rich, triple-cream. Triple-reducing heavy cream will give you a thicker and richer sauce.

  • Butter

Did you know that Fettuccine Alfredo can be made only with cheese and butter? Yup, no cream, no eggs. These two ingredients are enough to make a thick, creamy sauce. You can also add more butter to your cheese. Butter is a mixture of milk and protein that emulsifies when it comes in contact with cheese. Mix 1 teaspoon butter in your Alfredo sauce. Cook on medium heat, frequently stirring until you achieve the desired consistency.

  • Cream cheese

Cream cheese can give the sauce the desired richness or thickness. The cream cheese can be cut into smaller pieces and added to the sauce while it is still heating in the saucepan. Mix all ingredients well. Adjust the thickness by adding enough cheese.

Stir it in until smooth. This process can take some time and should be done on low heat to avoid the cheese burning. The freshly shredded cheese melts much better than the pre-shredded. The cream cheese will give the cheese a little more tang.

  • Egg yolk

Egg yolk has been used for centuries as a thickener, emulsifier, and other purposes. It can be used correctly to make a great thickener in alfredo sauce.

Beat the egg yolk in a bowl until smooth. Once the yolk has become soft, slowly add the alfredo to the bowl, one ladle at a time, until it reaches a cup. Continue whisking until the egg and sauce mixture is smooth and creamy. 

Once the egg mixture is smooth and frothy, add it to the remaining alfredo. Bring it to boil until thickened. Don’t add the whisked egg directly to the alfredo, as it can ruin the consistency of the sauce, especially if it is too hot.

  • Shredded cheese

You can make Alfredo sauce better by adding some good quality cheese you chopped yourself. You can also buy pre-shredded cheese in the cheese section if you need it. Be aware that not all brands melt well, so make sure to choose a brand you have had success with in the past.

To shred a block of cheese, you can use a food processor or box grater. You might try different types of cheese depending on what you prefer.

  • Add Potato

Potatoes are a great way to add creaminess to alfredo sauce. Cut two potatoes into small pieces and boil them until soft. Mix it with butter and olive oils and cook it on medium heat until it becomes a paste. Salt and pepper to taste. Stir in cream cheese or sour milk until it becomes creamy. 

  • Roux

A roux is the most common way to make alfredo sauce. A roux combines fat (most commonly butter) and a thickening agent (mostly flour). To make a paste, butter is first melted in a saucepan. Then the flour is added to the pan. Next, a liquid is added to the paste. Then Alfredo is made. Usually, milk or heavy cream is used.

  • Tapioca powder

Tapioca flour is known for its distinctive taste. To thicken the alfredo sauce, you can use it the same way as the roux. It can be added to butter and cream or diluted in water as flour. It tastes great in any way. Tapioca might not be available, but it’s worth the effort.

How to serve the sauce?

Fettuccine Alfredo has become a classic. It is so good that you can’t imagine using Alfredo sauce in any other way. The sauce’s rich, creamy texture and rich, cheesy flavor make it a great pairing with various dishes, including meats, vegetables, crudites, and casseroles.

Use Alfredo sauce to dip fresh vegetables or crackers for parties or when you prepare Alfredo sauce as a marinade for fish or chicken. You can also use it on pizzas, casseroles, or drizzled over roasted vegetables. This delicious sauce is versatile. You can use it on anything, but ensure it’s not too thin or watery.

Wrapping Up

Alfredo sauce is simply delicious. It’s not as good, though it is a little too thick. There are many ways to thicken the sauce. You will have a thick sauce if you go too far in these techniques. You can always add some milk. This sauce is versatile, but make sure you serve it hot!

Checkout: Can you freeze alfredo sauce to consume later without any issues here

homemade thick alfredo

Frequently Asked Questions

Can you thicken Alfredo sauce using flour?

The starch gives your Alfredo a lovely thickness. It is essential to cook the flour well as it can leave a bitter taste. Mix three tablespoons of flour with half a cup of water until the mixture is well-combined. Mix the mixture with the sauce. Stir until it becomes thick.

Does simmering thicken sauces?

Let the sauce simmer in a saucepan until it reaches the desired consistency. To allow liquids to evaporate, keep the pot covered. To prevent sauce separation or curdling, avoid boiling the liquid. Remember that simmering will intensify the sauce’s flavor.

Why is my pasta sauce so watery?

Too much pasta water in the spaghetti sauce can often lead to a watery sauce. You can also get watery sauces from too many noodles or insufficiently cooking the sauce.

How do you keep Alfredo creamy?

It is essential not to overheat your Alfredo Sauce. This Sauce is thickened and creamy by using Parmesan cheese. We recommend using fresh parmesan cheese, which you can grate or something similar. Avoid using powdered or grated Parmesan cheese in tall cans.

Will Alfredo sauce thicken as it cools?

As long as the Alfredo sauce is made with a traditional recipe that includes butter and Parmesan cheese, it will thicken when it cools. Consider that Alfredo sauce should always be served hot or mildly warm.

Is butter making Alfredo sauce thinner?

Butter can thicken Alfredo sauces, making them thicker. Butter is rich and can cause problems.

Rate this post

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *