Substitute For Stewed Tomatoes

Fresh tomatoes cooked in salt with various spices are referred to as stewed tomatoes. They typically contain bell peppers, onions, garlic, and celery. They can be cooked and served as a snack or in soups, sauces, or stews. Every American offers a unique method of cooking stewed tomatoes. Substitute For Stewed Tomatoes shared below will help you to make tasty recipes easily in your kitchen.

Certain varieties may include vegetables, while others prefer traditional cooking using only tomatoes and spices. Stewed tomatoes may sound like an ordinary ingredient, but they provide numerous recipes with a rich and hearty flavor. They add acidity and sweetness to dishes that are impossible to replicate by using other ingredients.


Alternatives and Substitutes For Stewed Tomatoes

While it’s an important ingredient in many recipes, stewed tomatoes may be difficult to locate in many places. Below, we have summed up some ingredients to replicate stewed tomatoes.

Crushed Tomatoes

Crushed tomatoes are generally smooth and easy to pour. Crushed tomatoes are the closest alternatives you’ll come across in stewed tomatoes due to their size and texture. These are bursting with a fresh and sweet taste. Because of these qualities, the crushed tomatoes make a great addition to creamy stews or pasta soup. They also make an excellent pizza sauce or an excellent addition to your delicious ravioli lasagna.

Crushed tomatoes can be a fantastic substitute for stewed tomatoes since the tomatoes are softened, then broken down exactly like stewed tomatoes. They’ll provide the same type of texture you would get from your regular stewed tomatoes. 

Crushed tomatoes can be canned, and their texture is a mix of tomato sauce and diced tomatoes. The crushed tomatoes have an intense flavor and favorite for creamy soups. You are welcome to add other spices and vegetables to recreate the flavor of stewed tomatoes as you would normally. Some brands, however, offer smaller chunks of tomato, making their texture denser.

If you prefer them to be more chunky or soft, choose the right brand and carefully read the label. This is an excellent ingredient for your kitchen and is often available in many kitchens. You can also cut your tomatoes and use freshly diced tomatoes as an alternative.

Crushed tomato is a hefty and chunky tomato mixture cooked for less than an hour to ensure that the water absorbed evaporates and intensifies the flavor that the tomatoes provide. The easiest method to crush whole tomatoes is using an immersion blender to give them an even, smoother consistency. Crushed tomatoes are great in all dishes where you’re looking to substitute tomatoes that have been stewed.

They’re typically good in heavy dishes since crushed tomatoes have a less liquid consistency than whole or diced tomatoes. If you’re searching for tomatoes as a base for the form of a meat dish, crushed tomatoes could be the best option.

crushed tomatoes

Diced Tomatoes

Diced tomatoes can be an excellent alternative to stewed tomatoes. They are tiny square pieces of tomatoes cut into pieces and canned with the liquid. However, stewed tomatoes come in large soft pieces, which is why they are cooked slightly and not simmered. In certain varieties, the diced tomatoes can be salted or lightly spiced. A few diced tomatoes may be cooked to give a smokey flavor. A few twists make this dish an excellent alternative to the stewed tomato. 

In the beginning, cook it longer to create a smoother texture. After that, if you wish to add onion or garlic to it, you are free to add it. The addition of additional seasonings will enhance the taste of your meals and make them delicious. If you decide to make substitutes for stewed tomatoes, be ready to put in a little more work. The result is small cubes that look similar to chopped vegetables. They can be preserved or fresh and serve well as a substitute for stewed tomatoes!

When you choose diced tomatoes, it is best to choose canned tomatoes that are low in sodium or have no salt added. Also, you should avoid the cans that have sugar added. Canned tomatoes or diced tomatoes (whole) are ideal when you don’t need many tomatoes cooked. It is necessary to cook them an additional time on the stove to achieve the soft texture stewed tomatoes provide. You can add a few additional spices, and you’re ready to go and serve with your roasted veggies!

diced tomatoes

Cherry Tomatoes

Like fresh tomatoes, you’ll have to cook to soften them like stewed tomatoes. Many online recipes online will help you accomplish this. After being cooked, they’re an excellent substitute for stewed tomatoes! It is important to note that the taste isn’t the same as traditional tomatoes. You can spice it up with other vegetables such as onions and green bell peppers to give them a similar taste to stewed tomatoes. 

The stunning, bright tomatoes are a tiny but potent nutritional powerhouse. These tiny tomatoes fight off illnesses like influenza and may even help slow the growth of cancerous cells! They’re a great source of vitamins C, A, K, and potassium that aid in maintaining normal blood pressure as well as circulation throughout the body. Incorporate these tasty tomatoes into your favorite recipes for a quick way to enhance the health benefits of tomatoes. They’re great for pickle or canning, and you can create vibrant, festive fresh homemade sauce containers. 

They might not be as robust as other tomatoes, but they are easy to chop up to make salads, thanks to their soft skin. Cut into pizza sauce, pasta, and paninis, or take them similarly when you’re craving a taste of summer. In a single portion (about three-quarters of an ounce) in a serving, you’ll find just 30 calories and three grams of carbs in cherry tomatoes. This is lower than other fruits with a similar calorie count!

cherry tomato image

Tomato Paste

Tomato paste is a great alternative to stewed tomatoes and is something you may already have in your refrigerator! Tomato paste is made by dehydrating tomatoes, removing water, and concentrating the flavor. The most distinctive feature of tomatoes is their capacity to maintain their properties even after being heated. Thus, tomato paste made from natural tomatoes is a highly healthy food item. Like tomato sauce, tomato paste is also dense. In contrast to tomato sauce, the flavor of tomato paste is very strong. It is more robust than stewed tomato sauce!

The umami taste of tomatoes can be found in tomato paste. If you wish to lessen the intensity of this flavor, you can add water or another vegetable such as celery to your dish. This well-known product, tomato paste, enhances the flavor of marinades, soups, sauces, and lechos and makes them denser. The color is intense, bright appealing. It’s a fantastic substitute for stewed tomatoes in soups and provides that strong tomato taste. 

If you include other vegetables such as onions or bell peppers, you will not notice anything different from tomatoes stewed in tomato paste. Although it may sound rough, it’s a fantastic product that can’t be replicated in any other method. It’s excellent for lasagna or chili or to substitute stewed tomatoes as it packs a lot of tomato flavor in a highly concentrated form. Therefore, if you’re looking for a smooth thin sauce, tomato paste may be the best option. 

Canned Whole Tomatoes

Whole tomatoes are peeled to preserve their seeds. They are usually packaged as juice in the form of a can. They are often regarded as an alternative to stewed tomatoes in stews, pasta, sauces, and other dishes. Canned tomatoes are made from plum tomatoes due to their an extended shelf life.

They are firm in texture, and the seeds are removed in their entirety and then canned with the juices. The whole tomato is an excellent source with various options and can be cooked in a way you like the taste of a dish.

If you use this substitute, you can alter it to match the desired taste or texture. Crush or chop the tomatoes into whole pieces to create a more smooth texture. You can crush the tomatoes in their entirety like many cooks before adding them to your meal.

It is also possible to add juice if you look for an extra tomato taste. It is possible to make whole tomato stew (canned) using about 1/4 cup of chopped bell pepper and about 1/4 cup of chopped onion. This will give you a more delicious and fresher taste than canned stewed tomatoes.

canned tomatoes

Tomato Sauce

Tomato sauce is made up of pureed, peeled, and flavorful tomatoes. The sauce is entirely free of tomato seeds and is closest to the stewed tomatoes if you evaluate the flavor and cooking times. But, it will differ in texture as it is smooth and thicker than stewed tomatoes. Certain brands add additional ingredients to boost the flavor of tomato sauce, including onion, garlic, spices, herbs, and sugar. It has a syrupy consistency and a soft texture.

If you’re looking to spice canned tomato sauce by yourself, opt for the unseasoned sauce. It is also possible to add bell peppers or onions into the tomato sauce to create more suitable stewed tomatoes. The tomato sauce is similar to tomato paste; however, its texture isn’t as uniform. Some brands of tomato sauce contain onions, cheese, basil, and sugar. But it does not have tomato chunks as tomato paste has. This sauce is ideal for chicken recipe, pasta, creamy stews, and pizza sauce toppings.

In particular, a cup of stewed tomato could be replaced with a 3/4th portion of tomato sauce. Knowing this ratio will assist you in getting a better taste for your food. Use this alternative only if your dish already contains excessive liquid. 


Tomato Puree

You can also use tomato puree instead of stewed tomatoes. Tomato puree is made from Roma tomatoes which are passed through an aerator. A few people might want to warm the pulp after sieving so that it is easier to get rid of the liquid that has accumulated.

Like crushed tomatoes, tomato paste is a suitable alternative since the tomatoes have broken down already and are, in this instance, purified. It is a firm texture as well as a delicious flavor. If you’re using tomato puree as an alternative to stewed tomatoes, ensure to reduce the amount of tomato puree the recipe requires. 

The greatest benefit of using tomato purée instead of stewed tomatoes is it resembles the texture of canned or pureed diced tomatoes. You can use it in any dish regardless of whether the recipe calls for crushed tomatoes. It is also possible to use tomato puree or tomato paste to substitute for stewed tomatoes even though you don’t heat them. However, they might alter the flavor of the dish.

Tomato puree

Spaghetti Sauce

It’s a great alternative for oils and stews when cooking, but it also tastes similar to your grandmother’s kitchen. You can add meatballs to serve with it if you’d like. It is renowned for its use as an alternative to stewed tomatoes in recipes. Delicious and sweet plum tomatoes are grown near our house near Chicago for this sauce. The thick sauce comes with a rich and simple ingredient list to ensure it is fresh and healthy.

In the salsa pasta sauce, it is possible to enjoy the creamy texture that will provide the taste you want without those tomato seeds that cling to your teeth. The sauce is low in calories but also high in protein. Take a bite with plain old noodles and experience what you think! A savory flavor explodes with every bite that you take.


Frequently Asked Questions

Can I Use Crushed Tomatoes Instead Of Stewed Tomatoes?

Crushed tomatoes make a wonderful alternative to stewed tomatoes. They are typically tomatoes that have been freshly blended to a smooth consistency and then canned with a pureed mixture. Hence. they can be used when recipes call for stewed tomatoes and vice versa.

What’s the taste of Stewed Tomatoes Taste Like?

The stewed tomatoes are mild in taste and have a mildly acidic taste; however, they’re typically mixed with flavors such as garlic, onion, or basil to enhance the flavor. While stewing tomatoes, try to lower the water since this will help concentrate the sweet and tangy taste even more!

Are canned tomatoes beneficial for you?

Many people enjoy canned tomatoes because they are useful, practical, and cost-effective. It is important to remember that tomatoes are a great source of minerals and vitamins. The canning process could remove some fiber and vitamin C, but there are abundant nutrients that remain. In addition, canned tomatoes are high in the carotenoid pigment, lycopene. This antioxidant reduces the risk of macular degeneration, heart disease, and cancer.

Rate this post

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *